Claims Litigated Under Government Claims Act Must “Fairly Reflect” Factual Claims Made in Underlying Government Claim
November 27, 2023 —
Garret Murai - California Construction Law BlogUnlike horseshoes and hand grenades, close sometimes isn’t close enough.
In the next case, Hernandez v. City of Stockton, 90 Cal.App.5th 1222 (2023), the Third District Court of appeal found that a pedestrian who sued a public entity for personal injuries caused by an “uplifted sidewalk” was barred from pursuing his claim when it was revealed that he had in fact injured himself by falling into a hole left by an “empty tree well” (i.e., a tree well that did not contain a tree”). According to the Court, the pedestrian’s claim was barred because the factual basis for recovery asserted in his complaint was not “fairly reflected” in his government claim.
The Hernandez Case
In April 2018, pedestrian Manual Sanchez Hernandez injured himself while walking on a public sidewalk in Stockton, California. He submitted a government claim with the City of Stockton claiming that his injuries, which included injuries to his knee, hands and back, was caused by a dangerous condition on public property. In his government claim, Hernandez alleged that he tripped on an “uplifted sidewalk” at or near 230 E. Charter Way in Stockton, California and that his injuries were due because the City “negligently and recklessly designed, maintained and operated the subject property so as to cause [his] injuries.”
Read the full story...Reprinted courtesy of
Garret Murai, Nomos LLPMr. Murai may be contacted at
gmurai@nomosllp.com
Gibbs Giden is Pleased to Announce Four New Partners and Two New Associates
January 08, 2024 —
Gibbs Giden Locher Turner Senet & Wittbrodt, LLPWe take great pleasure in announcing that
Richard Marks and
Kyle Marks have joined the firm. They bring a combined 60 years of real property law experience to Gibbs Giden. Well known Title Insurance and seasoned real estate attorneys they have both served as chair of the Title Insurance Subsection of the Los Angeles County Bar Association and are adjunct professors at Southwestern University School of Law. We are excited to welcome these two exceptional partners and their commitment to representing clients with honesty, integrity, and excellence. You can find them in our firm’s Westlake office.
Talented attorneys
Samantha Riggen and
Christopher Trembley have been named partners. Samantha represents clients in all areas of business and commercial matters with an emphasis on construction litigation on both public and private projects. Christopher’s practice also focuses on construction litigation on behalf of a wide spectrum of industry-stakeholder clients, including suppliers, contractors, and owners. Both work in our firm’s Westlake Village office.
We are also pleased to announce we’ve hired two new associates.
Sarah La Mendola and
Madison Wedderspoon. Sarah has developed an expertise in a wide range of real estate, business, and corporate matters. She received her JD from the University of Pavia, one of the top universities in Italy, in 2012 and her LLM from UCLA in 2015. You can find Sarah in our Westlake Village office. Madison recently graduated from the Boyd School of Law cum laude, is based in our Las Vegas office and works in the areas of business law, contracts, healthcare law, construction, real estate, and common interest community transactional and litigation work.
Read the full story...Reprinted courtesy of
Gibbs Giden
How to Prevent Forest Fires by Building Cities With More Wood
December 16, 2023 —
Leslie Kaufman - BloombergDeep in Colville National Forest in eastern Washington state, Russ Vaagen is pointing to a delineation between woods that have been selectively thinned and those that haven’t. One side is light-filled and punctuated with meadows; the other is dense and dark and loaded with trees losing a Darwinian battle for water and life.
To Vaagen it’s proof that America’s sawmills and lumberjacks can help head off the forest conflagrations that are becoming
ever more common, and at the same time provide raw material for an
emerging industry, known as
mass timber, that makes sustainable wood building components.
Read the full story...Reprinted courtesy of
Leslie Kaufman, Bloomberg
Products Liability Law – Application of Economic Loss Rule
April 02, 2024 —
David Adelstein - Florida Construction Legal UpdatesWhen it comes to product liability law, one important doctrine that will always come up is the economic loss rule. The economic loss rule, oftentimes going by its acronym ELR, lives and breathes in the realm of product liability law.
Does the economic loss rule extend to a manufacturer’s distributor for a duty to warn when the product is NOT defective? A recent opinion out of the Eleventh Circuit Court of Appeals, NBIS Construction & Transport Ins. Services v. Liebherr-America, Inc., 2024 WL 861257 (11th Cir. 2024), was confronted with this question, including whether the economic loss rule should even extend to a distributor of a product, and certified the following to Florida’s Supreme Court to answer: “Whether, under Florida law, the economic loss rule applies to negligence claims against a distributor of a product, stipulated to be non-defective, for the failureto alert a product owner of a known danger, when the only damages claimed are to the product itself?” NBIS, supra, at *8.
Read the full story...Reprinted courtesy of
David Adelstein, Kirwin Norris, P.A.Mr. Adelstein may be contacted at
dma@kirwinnorris.com
Insurer’s Broad Duty to Defend in Oregon, and the Recent Ruling in State of Oregon v. Pacific Indemnity Company
January 02, 2024 —
Keith Sparks - Ahlers Cressman & Sleight PLLCOregon law mandates a broad duty to defend, requiring insurers to provide legal representation to their policyholders whenever there is a potential for coverage under the policy. The significance of this broad interpretation means that an insurer has a duty to defend an insured even in situations where the alleged facts only imply a covered claim, and even in situations where the underlying claim is ultimately not covered by the policy. The insurer’s duty to defend is triggered if the allegations of the complaint, reasonably interpreted, could result in the insured being held liable for damages covered by the policy. This is referred to as the “four-corners” rule; it is also sometimes referred to as the eight-corners rule (for the four corners of the complaint plus the four corners of the policy). Oregon’s adoption of a broad interpretation of the duty to defend affirmatively places the onus on insurers to err on the side of coverage.
This broad duty to defend is based on the principle that an insured should not have to bear the expense of defending a lawsuit that the insurer may ultimately have to pay for. The duty to defend is also important because it helps ensure that insureds have access to legal representation when faced with a lawsuit.
Read the full story...Reprinted courtesy of
Keith Sparks, Ahlers Cressman & Sleight PLLCMr. Sparks may be contacted at
keith.sparks@acslawyers.com
HB24-1014: A Warning Bell for Colorado Businesses Amid Potential Consumer Protection Changes
February 26, 2024 —
Jennifer Brockel - Colorado Construction Litigation BlogHB24-1014 stands to eliminate the longstanding public impact requirement found within C.R.S. § 6-1-105(2) of the Colorado Consumer Protection Act (“CCPA”). While this proposed change professes the noblest intentions of “public peace, health or safety,” its effect portends a large detriment to Colorado business and an astronomical payday for Colorado plaintiffs’ attorneys.
Brief History
For over 100 years, Colorado recognized the need to protect its citizens from deceptive trade practices through a mechanism akin to the Federal Trade Commission Act that preceded it. In 1915, Colorado passed legislation prohibiting “untrue, deceptive, or misleading” advertising. C.L. 1921 § 6942 evolved into the broader protections afforded in the more recent consumer protection law from 1969 that prohibited “deceptive trade practices, and included protections from unfair, unconscionable, and deceptive acts or practices.”
Read the full story...Reprinted courtesy of
Jennifer Brockel, Higgins, Hopkins, McLain & Roswell, LLCMs. Brockel may be contacted at
brockel@hhmrlaw.com
To Ease Housing Crunch, Theme Parks Are Becoming Homebuilders
January 29, 2024 —
Patrick Sisson - BloombergFor visitors, Universal Studios Florida offers a chance to visit a fantastical land full of wizards, Minions and various characters from NBC Universal’s many film and television properties. But for the roughly 28,000 men and women who work at the 840-acre theme park and resort complex in Orlando, the troubles of the real world — like the rising cost of housing — are not far away.
Central Florida has seen some of the nation’s fastest pandemic-era rent increases, thanks to a confluence of job growth, migration and housing underproduction that has put a strain on residents. The average tenant in the region saw their monthly rent jump by $600 between early 2020 and early 2023. According to the National Low Income Housing Coalition, the Orlando-Kissimmee-Sanford metro area has one of the worst affordable housing shortages in the US, with only 15 available units for every 100 extremely low-income renter households.
The dire need for workforce housing is behind the entertainment conglomerate’s la
Fence Attached to Building Covered Under Dwelling ProvisionsCGL Policy May Not Cover Cybersecurity and Data-Related LossesGeneral Liability Alert: A Mixed Cause of Action with Protected and Non-Protected Activity Not Subject to Anti-SLAPP MotionSummary Judgment Granted to Insurer for Hurricane DamageJury Finds Broker Liable for Policyholder’s Insufficient Business Interruption LimitsPennsylvania Reconstruction Project Beset by ProblemsNo Duty to Defend Under Renter's PolicyBurden Supporting Termination for DefaultContractor's Agreement to Perform Does Not Preclude Coverage Under Contractual Liability ExclusionSouth Carolina Couple Must Arbitrate Construction Defect ClaimLouisiana District Court Declines to Apply Total Pollution ExclusionIs an Initial Decision Maker, Project Neutral, or Dispute Resolution Board Right for You?Construction Law Alert: Unlicensed Contractors On Federal Projects Entitled To Payment Under The Miller ActDrywall Originator Hopes to Sell in AsiaIncorporation, Indemnity and Statutes of Limitations, Oh My!Former Hoboken, New Jersey Mayor Disbarred for Taking BribesGuilty Pleas Draw Renewed Interest In Nevada’s Construction Defect LawsRe-Thinking the One-Sided Contract: Considerations for a More Balanced Approach
Edward Beitz and William Taylor Recognized by US News – Best Lawyers as a "Lawyer of the Year"
What is Toxic Mold Litigation?
Insurer Awarded Summary Judgment on Collapse Claim
The Unthinkable Has Happened. How Should Contractors Respond?
Insurer Must Defend Claims of Alleged Willful Coal Removal
Water Damage: Construction’s Often Unnoticed Threat
Home Prices in 20 U.S. Cities Increased 4.3% in November
Statute of Limitations and Bad Faith Claims: Factors to Consider
The Dog Ate My Exclusion! – Georgia Federal Court: No Reformation to Add Pollution Exclusion
No Coverage Under Installation Policy When Read Together with Insurance Application
The Court of Appeals Holds That Indifference to Safety Satisfies the Standard for a Willful Violation Under WISHA
Texas Public Procurements: What Changed on September 1, 2017? a/k/a: When is the Use of E-Verify Required?
Additional Dismissals of COVID Business Interruption, Civil Authority Claims
FAA Plans Final Regulation on Commercial Drone Use by Mid-2016
Hawaii Court Looks at Changes to Construction Defect Coverage after Changes in Law
Diggerland, UK’s Construction Equipment Theme Park, is coming to the U.S.
Trump Abandons Plan for Council on Infrastructure
Justin Clark Joins Newmeyer & Dillion’s Walnut Creek Branch as its Newest Associate
Coping with Labor & Install Issues in Green Building
Increase in Single-Family New Home Sales Year-Over-Year in January
Public Law Center Honors Snell & Wilmer Partner Sean M. Sherlock As Volunteers For Justice Attorney Of The Year
BHA Sponsors 28th Annual Construction Law Conference in San Antonio, TX
Homebuyers Aren't Sweating the Fed
Negligent Failure to Respond to Settlement Offer Is Not Bad Faith
New LG Headquarters Project Challenged because of Height
EPA Coal Ash Cleanup Rule Changes Send Utilities, Agencies Back to Drawing Board
California to Build ‘Total Disaster City’ for Training
Alert: AAA Construction Industry Rules Update
Home Prices in 20 U.S. Cities Kept Climbing in January
Ohio “property damage” caused by an “occurrence.”
Truck Hits Warning Beam That Falls, Kills Motorist at Las Vegas Bridge Project
Terminating Contracts for Convenience — “Just Because”
Feds Used Wire to Crack Las Vegas HOA Scam
Pollution Exclusion Prevents Coverage for Injury Caused by Insulation
Sensors for Smarter Construction – Interview with Laura Kassovic of MbientLab
COVID-19 Damages and Time Recovery: Contract Checklist and Analysis
ConsensusDOCS Updates its Forms
Loan Modifications Due to COVID-19 Pandemic: FDIC Answers CARES Act FAQs
Mandatory Arbitration Provision Upheld in Construction Defect Case
Yet ANOTHER Reason not to Contract without a License
After Sixty Years, Subcontractors are Back in the Driver’s Seat in Bidding on California Construction Projects
Court of Appeal Holds That Higher-Tiered Party on Construction Project Can be Held Liable for Intentional Interference with Contract
Not Everything is a Pollutant: A Summary of Recent Cases Supporting a Common Sense and Narrow Interpretation of the CGL's Pollution Exclusion
Another Case Highlighting the Difference Between CGL Policies and Performance Bonds
Insurer's Quote on Coverage for Theft by Hacker Creates Issue of Fact
Value in Recording Lien within Effective Notice of Commencement
Construction Warranties: Have You Seen Me Lately?
Protect Your Right To Payment By Following Nedd
Another Reminder to ALWAYS Show up for Court
Nevada Legislature Burns Insurers' Rights to Offer Eroding Limits
